2009 Picture/Video Card Viewer Analysis - 05/02/2009 Back to Main Review Page
   
 

 

There is always a period of time in the spring that things finally begin to slow down and we have normally just filled it up with gathering the pictures and videos from the multitude of cameras we have in our long range tests. This year we decided to take a look at these camera accessories and try to give a review on their function. This was probably one of the biggest can of worms that we ever opened. Nothing is standard, even the labels and terms for operation varied from unit to unit. The documentation was written in some cases so poorly that I just could not follow the instructions. By trial and error I managed to work my way through each one and done a feeble attempt to report my findings. I will say that every unit tested did work, but in some cases not very well. Most of the testing is on going and there are still areas that we have not been able to test. Maybe there is an issue on the unit or maybe there is a difference in format causing the problems. Every unit tested did handle the JPG pictures with out problems. Some were very easy to use and some required a bunch of toggling to select and play the first picture and then more to continue. Some of the viewers were very slow to load the pictures and if you had 50 or 60 pictures to look at you had better find you a good soft spot to park your butt in the shade because you are going to be there a while. Probably the biggest complaint we have seen so far is that one camera company to another they choose to use some different format and this requires that you purchase a viewer of that same brand name to accomplish this task. SD and CF cards seem to be the two most used cards in scouting cameras. Select few readers will view both style cards, some read only SD cards, and some read pictures, some read pictures and videos. For those of you who run a lot of cameras you may have several different brand name cameras deployed. If this is the case, then you may have to own more than one viewer to be able to view your pictures/videos in the field. At a cost average of $150 each then this makes a pair get into the 300 dollar range. I took a trip to Wally World and in their computer section they had a small lap top that had a built in set of card slots for about $250 and was loaded with home version of Micro soft windows. This might be another option for field use and still remain portable. Being that the majority of our viewing is on SD cards I have taken note that I have reached for just one viewer most every time. I will go through the brands and speak a little about each one in general because the in depth reviews are still on going. The one that I reached for most of the time will be the last in the narrative. In our particular case we most always have one of our lap tops with us but when you are in the back 40 and find where someone or something has screwed with a cam then you can pull the card and get immediate information. For those who use their viewer with a base card and copy to it  so you can return the card to the cam that it came out of prior to moving to the next cam, you are going to be there a while. This is not an instant function. Having enough cards to just swap out may be a better option. (a 2 gig is under $10 now) They have their place in the world of scouting cameras, you just have to figure out just how well a selected viewer will fit in your situation.
 
Cuddeback CuddeView 4-in-1 Viewer
Very slick operating viewer, nice screen, does SD and CF cards, easy to use, rechargeable LI, no video capability and loads pretty fast.

StealthCam STC-CRV20 Card Viewer
Probably the best functioning of the viewers, because of its capabilities to do all cards, copy SD to SD, do video in most formats except Leaf River, nice rubber armor, Small screen and very slow to load. Instructions and function as written were easy to understand. 

Leaf River PV-2.5 Multi-Card Viewer
The toggle function to view did not seem to work very well. Very stiff and had a tendency not to accept my requests. It accepts all the cards but will only play video from the Leaf River cameras. I have yet to get to get that function to work but instructions indicate the method but my attempts to view several cards from one of out IR-7 cameras in the video mode have failed. I am still working on this. The method to view requires toggling through files to make it happen. Loading was somewhat slow but the nice screen size made sharp and clear viewing when it happened.
 
Spypoint PV-2.4 Digital Picture Viewer
This is some type of multi-media device plus it is a SD card viewer. Of the viewers, seen so far this has been the most difficult to use and has a very slow load time. The many functions like having a radio get in the way of the business of being an easy to use reader. It does work and does work well when figured out but has a learning curve associated with its use. I have to log a few more hours in the field with this viewer before I give a final decision as to function.
 
Custom1Enterprises Envue Field Picture Viewer
This is the last in the series so far and there might be a couple more on the way in but delays because of year model are keeping from us getting 100 % of available viewers. Custom one decided to just take the simple route go out and find a small digital picture frame that seems to double as a viewer very well. No frills, no copy function, no video function, no multi card slots, just a plain old SD card viewer. Turn the switch on with the card installed and hit the slide show button is all it takes to view your pictures on a 3.5 inch screen. As I said above, when I am in the field and have this sack full of viewers and I want to see what is on a particular SD card in a hurry I will reach for this unit. I will say that this viewer may not be as rugged as the others but a little protection by using the wallet that it comes with should keep it in peak shape for a long time. We have only a few cams out anymore that use the CF cards and they are all Reconyx cameras which take an enormous amount of pictures each week which makes trying to view that amount in the field impractical so we have to swap and run unless we find a situation has happened in that test area.
 
Bushnell Viewer:
Bushnell declined to have a unit tested at this time due to them having a very new updated Viewer on the way out for 09. When ever it becomes available we will see if we can get out hands on one.
 

Conclusion

These are very useful devices and in most cases function very well. If you are running multi brand name cameras and use both the picture and video capabilities of your cameras then having a small laptop like the acer 8 inch would be advisable. The computer will perform all the functions and do it faster plus will have storage and transferability that some may require. They are larger and require prior planning before venturing in the field. This means some type of protective case for your mini computer. Most of the time we are on some type of ATV so the load is not an issue. If I had to do my route on foot then the portable reader that would slip into a shirt pocket would have to come up as first choice. Some thought must be put into your selection. Good luck 

 

   

Copyright 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010 Chasingame.com
Your Source for scouting camera reviews, performance ratings, sample photos and movies, performance and stress testing.

Please read our disclaimer:
As an independent consumer review site our goal is to provide as accurately as possible, our experiences with the cameras and equipment we test.  Our findings are based solely on the units we test as are the results.  Our statements reflect only our opinions unless stated otherwise.  We take pride in being accurate and make every attempt to communicate with manufacturers about our findings.  We do not sell cameras, accept kickbacks, or own stock in any camera manufacturers.
Thank you for visiting Chasingame.com.